CENTER ON BEHAVIORAL MEDICINE

BODY-MIND CONNECTION

PSYCHOLOGICAL - SOCIAL ENVIRONMENT

Psychological - Social Environment:  Research Article
Psychological-Social Environment Menu

Media Violence and Degree of Acceptance

CITATION:  Vidal, M.A., Clemente, M., and Espinosa, Pablo.  (2003).  Types of Media Violence and Degree of Acceptance in Under-18s. Aggressive Behavior. Volume 29, pages 381—392

ABSTRACT:   It is an established fact that almost every TV channel offers a high level of violent content. The object of this study is to check the degree of acceptance of this media violence in under-18s. We will also check what cognitive and emotional effects the viewing of different types of violence has. 

A sample of 203 subjects aged 13 years from Madrid, Spain, viewed a clip from different films. Before and after the film, data were collected about their opinion on violence. Three viewing conditions were established according to the degree and type of violence shown and based on Berkowitz 1(1996): Desclee De Brouwer: action without violence, socially justified violence, and socially unjustified violence. 

Several ANOVAs were carried out revealing that violence is better valued and more attractive after watching the film sequences than before the showing. 

References

Anderson CA. 1997. Effects of violent movies and trait hostility on hostile feelings and aggressive thoughts. Aggr Behav 23:161-178.

Bandura A. 1996. Teoria social cognitiva de la comunicacion de masas. In: Bryant J, Zillmann D, comps. Los efectos de los medios de comunicacion: investigaciones y teorias. Barcelona: Paidos. p 89-126.

Bandura A, Walters RH. 1974. Aprendizaje social y desarrollo de la
personalidad. Madrid: Alianza. Berkowitz L. 1996. Agresion: causas, 
consecuencias y control. Bilbao: Desclee De Brouwer.

Berkowitz L, Powers PC. 1979. Effects of timing and justification of witnessed aggression on the observers punitiveness. J Res Pers 13:71-80.

Clemente M. 1998. Violencia, medios de comunicacion y Winos y jovenes. In: Sanmartin J, Grisolia JS. Grisolia S, editors. Violencia, television y cine. Barcelona: Ariel. p 67-85.

Clemente M, Vidal MA. 1994. La violencia simbolica: la television como medio generador de delincuencia en los Winos. Apuntes de Psicologia 41-42:47-60.

Clemente M, Vidal MA. 1995. La violencia simbolica: In television como socializadora del menor. In: Centro de estudios juridicos: justicia con menores y jovenes. Madrid: Ministerio de Justicia e Interior. p 63-93.

Clemente M, Vidal MA. 1996. Violencia y television. Madrid: Noesis.

Clemente M, Vidal MA. 1997. La television como ente socializador del menor: los problemas de la violencia simbolica. In Urra J. Clemente M, cords. Psicologia juridica del menor. Madrid: Fundacion Universidad-Empresa. p 367-400.

Clemente M, Vidal MA. 2000. La socialization de In violencia culturalmente aceptada. In: Farina F, Arce R, cords. Psicologia juridica al servicio del menor. Madrid: Cedecs. p 75-91.

Clemente M, Vidal MA. Espinosa P. 1999. Repercusiones psiquicas en los menores del visionado mediatico de espectaculos taurinos. Madrid: Defensor del Menor en la Comunidad de Madrid.

Clemente M, Vidal MA, Espinosa P. 2000. Desarrollo sociomoral en Ios Winos a traves del juego. Santiago de Compostela: Xunta de Galicia.

Comstock G, Paik H. 1991. Television and the American child. San Diego. CA: Academic Press.

Drewer D, Hawkins JD, Catalano R, Neckerman H. 1995. Preventing serious. violent, and chronic juvenile offending: a review of evaluations of selected strategies in childhood, adolescence and the community. In: Hawkins JD, Wilson JJ, editors. Serious, violent and chronic juvenile offenders. Thousand Oaks: Sage. p 61 141.

Espinosa P, Clemente M, Vidal MA. 2002. Conducta antisocial y desarrollo moral en el menor: la (alta de conciencia civics y ecologica como factor conductual vinculado al razonamiento moral. Psicothema 14:26-36.

Garcia Galera MC. 2000. Television, violencia e infancia: el impacto de los medios. Barcelona: Gedisa.

Gerbner G, Gross L, Morgan M, Signorielli N. 1996. Crecer con la television: la perspectiva de aculturacion. In: Bryant J. Zillmann D, comps. Los efectos de los medios de comunicacion: investigaciones y teorias. Barcelona: Paidos. p 356.

Goldstein JH, ed. 1998. Why we watch? the attraction of violent entertainment. New York: Oxford University Press.

Gunter B. 1996. Acerca de la violencia de los media. In: Bryant J, Zillmann D, comps. Los efectos de los medios de comunicacion: investigaciones y teorias. 
Barcelona: Paidos. p 223-286.

Gunter B, McAleer J. 1997. Children and television. 2nd ed. London: Routledge.
11 nesmann LR, Eron LD. 1986. The development of aggression in American children as a consecuence of television viewing. In: Huesmann LR, Eron LD, editors. Television and the aggressive child: a cross-national comparison. Hillsdale. NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. p 45-80.

Huesmann LR. Lagerspetz K, Eron LD. 1984. Intervening variables in the TV-violence-aggression relation: evidence from two countries. Dev Psychol 20:746-745.

Huesmann LR, Moise J, Podolski CL, Eron LD. 1996. The roles of normative beliefs and fantasy rehearsal in mediating the observational learning of aggression. Abstract presented at: the International ISRA Meeting, August 25-30, Strasbourg, France.

Jo E, Berkowitz L. 1996. Andisis del efecto priming sobre la influencia de los media: una puesta al dia. In: Bryant J, Zillmann D, comps. Los efectos de los
medios de comunicacion: investigaciones y teorias. Barcelona: Paidos. p 67-88.

Krcmar M, Valkenburg PM. 1999. A scale to assess children's moral interpretations of justified and unjustified violence and its relationship to television viewing. Communication Res 26:608-634.

Leon JM, Cantero FJ, Gomez T. 1997. Efectos de la clasificacion del comportamiento del modelo simbo-Iico televisado sobre la agresividad infantil. Rev Psicologia Soc 12:31 -42.

Mustonen A. 1997. Nature of screen violence and its relation to program popularity. Aggr Behav 23:281-292.

Mustonen A, Pulkkinen L. 1993. Aggression in television programs in Finland. Aggr Behav 19:175-183_

Pena ME, Andreu JM, Munoz MJ. 1999. Efectos de la vision de escenas violentas en la conducta agresiva infantil. Psicothema 11:27-36.

Potter WJ. 1999. On media violence. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

Rowe DC, Herstand SE. 1986. Familiar influences on television viewing and aggression: a sibling study. Aggr Behav 12:111-120.

Rule BG. Ferguson TJ. 1986. The effects of media violence on attitudes, emotions and cognitions..1 Soc Issues 42:29-50.

l!rra J. Clemente M, Vidai MA. 2000. Television: impacto en la infancia. Madrid: Siglo XXI.

Vidal MA. 1999. La transmision intergeneracion>-rl de los valores. Sociedad y 
Utopia: 275--283.

Vidal MA. 2001. Delito y medios de cone nicacion social. In: Clemente M, Espinosa P, coords. La mentc criminal: teorias explicativas del delito desde la Psicologia Juridica. Madrid: Dikinson. p 193 207.

Vidal MA. Clemente M. 1998. El pensamiento social unico en la aldea global. Sociedad y Utopia 12:231 243.

Vidal MA, Clemente M. 2000. A atracao pela violencia mediatica. Psico 31:49-80.

Vilchez LF. 1999. Television y familia: un reto educativo. Madrid: PPC.
Von Feilitzen C. 1990. Tres tesis sobre los ninos y los medios de comunicacion. Infancia y Sociedad 3:31-47.

Walker KB, Morley DD. 1991. Attitudes and parental factors as intervening variables in the television violence-aggression relation. Communication Res Rep 8:41-47.